top of page

Convictions in Smyllum Park Case Unveil Decades of Orphanage Abuse

Justice has finally been served as two nuns and a care worker have been found guilty of horrendous acts of abuse against vulnerable children at the Smyllum Park orphanage in Lanark, Scotland. The convictions shed light on a disturbing chapter of historical abuse that plagued the institution from 1969 until its closure in 1981.

Sister Sarah McDermott, 79, Sister Eileen Igoe, 79, and carer Margaret Hughes, 76, were found guilty of subjecting children in their care to a series of cruel and inhumane incidents. The court heard harrowing testimonies of mistreatment and neglect inflicted upon these innocent youngsters.

The distressing content of the trial revealed the shocking extent of the abuse. One woman recounted how McDermott, upon learning of sexual abuse suffered by a three-year-old at the hands of another perpetrator, chose to punish the victim rather than investigate the heinous act. Instead of offering comfort, McDermott reprimanded the child for bringing "filthy home habits into a good Catholic place."

The extent of the physical abuse was equally appalling, with McDermott using rosary beads as a weapon and striking children repeatedly on their bodies and heads. Igoe, convicted of abusive acts including force feeding children and subjecting them to violent acts, was found guilty of similarly atrocious behavior.

Hughes, another perpetrator, exhibited a pattern of cruelty, forcefully submerging a girl in freezing water and subjecting a boy to physical assault. The court's decision to defer sentencing emphasizes the severity of these convictions and the gravity of the trauma inflicted on the victims.

Sheriff Scott Pattison's stern words highlighted the magnitude of the failure in duty and moral responsibility owed to these vulnerable children. Despite the denial of wrongdoing by the convicted individuals, the court's ruling stands as a testament to the suffering endured by those under their care.

The revelations from the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry in 2018 painted a distressing picture of the Smyllum Park orphanage, depicting a place marred by fear, threat, and excessive discipline. The report by Lady Smith, chairwoman of the inquiry, emphasized the absence of love, compassion, dignity, and comfort for the children at Smyllum.

The convictions mark a critical moment in acknowledging the historical abuse suffered by vulnerable children, underscoring the importance of accountability and justice. These heartbreaking revelations serve as a stark reminder of the immense responsibility society holds to protect the most vulnerable and ensure such atrocities never occur again.


bottom of page